Leading Authority in Pop Culture Collectibles Since 1990.
Across town or across the country, whether you’re buying, selling, or searching for the perfect treasure to start or complete your collection, Back to the Past Collectibles is one of the nation’s leading collectible dealers.
500,000+
Items Sold
Nationwide
Network of Buyers
35+
Years in Business
4.5
Stars on Google
Our Expertise
Serious Collectibles, Real Market Value.
From vintage comic books to classic vinyl records, iconic action figures, trading cards and more, we understand a broad array of collectibles and how to sell them for top dollar.
Comic Books
Comic books are where it all started for us, they’re in our DNA. With over 35 years of experience evaluating and selling comics from the Golden Age through modern key issues, we’ve built a reputation as a trusted source for comic book collectors and sellers alike.
Action Figures
Whether it’s a mint-in-box Kenner Star Wars figure or a loose 1970s Mego, our team has the know-how to assess what your action figures are truly worth. We’ve spent over three decades handling everything from classic GI Joes and Marvel ToyBiz to graded rarities and modern McFarlane collectibles and we’ve built a buyer network that’s always looking for the next great find.
Trading Cards
From classic Topps sets to Magic the Gathering and Pokemon, we study the market, evaluate condition, and build a strategy to get you the best possible return. Whether your cards have been in a binder on the shelf or tucked away in shoeboxes for decades, we have the expertise and the buyer network to make sure every card finds the right collector at the right price.
Vintage Toys
Every household seems to have a forgotten stash of toys hiding somewhere: an attic full of Marx playsets, a closet with old robots and space toys, a drawer of secret decoder rings. Don’t toss them during spring cleaning! We’ve been turning dusty toy collections into real dollars since 1990, and our team can spot the difference between a common find and a genuine treasure.
Movie Posters
Our love of movies runs deep. It’s baked right into our founding story alongside comic books and monster movies. From vintage one-sheets and lobby cards to press kits and publicity stills, we’re constantly on the lookout for film memorabilia that captures the magic of Hollywood’s greatest moments.
Video Games
From Atari cartridges and original Nintendo classics to sealed PlayStation titles and rare imports, we’ve watched the retro video game market explode and our team knows what separates a common bargain-bin find from a grail-worthy collectible. We bring that same sharp eye to every game, console, and accessory that comes through our doors.
Vinyl Records
We’re music lovers at heart, and yes, we’ll happily debate Beatles vs. Stones with you (our founder is a Stones guy, for the record). But when it comes to evaluating your vinyl collection, concert posters, or band t-shirts, we’re all business: we know the difference between a rare first pressing and a common reissue, and that knowledge translates directly into more money in your pocket.
Coins & Currency
The coin market moves fast, especially with metal prices escalating, and having a numismatist in your corner makes all the difference. Whether you’ve inherited a collection of Morgan silver dollars or you’re sitting on high-grade slabbed gold pieces, we’re ready to work with you to determine the best path to market, whether that’s a direct sale or showcasing your coins at one of our live auction events.
And more...
Almost every home holds a surprise or two, and we’ve built our reputation on uncovering value in the unexpected. Vintage role-playing games, old technology, unique ticket stubs, political memorabilia, promotional items… If it’s interesting, nostalgic, or one-of-a-kind, we want to see it.
What Our
Clients say
Don’t just take our word for it. Here’s what our clients have to say about us.
Chris C.
“Without a doubt, the best at what they do. You will not find a better place to buy, sale, or trade. Bottom line is they are good honest knowledgeable people. They put you first, you can rest assured you’re in good hands.”
Michigan
Mike G.
“I recently sold a collection of action figures that I have been holding onto for 40 years. These guys were very knowledgeable and paid me top value for my collection. More than I was expecting for sure.”
Michigan
Edward A.
“I recently partnered with Back to the Past to sell a collection…they communicated frequently and clearly…the auction even surpassed my expectations…friendly and easy to work with – I absolutely will use Back to the Past again!”
Ohio
Julie M.
“We feel so blessed we found you all when we did…we were especially impressed with the care and thoughtfulness taken in making sure our precious collections were handled and transported with the greatest of ease…we are truly grateful for your kindness…we will sing your praises to anyone who will listen!”
Florida
We Are Pop Culture Experts
We strive to exceed expectations at every turn, fostering a community where sellers and buyers find mutual satisfaction. Our success lies in the harmony between exceptional service, remarkable finds, and the joy of connecting collectors with cherished items.
Serving Collectors
Nationwide & Beyond
Leverage our strategic markets, platforms, and buyer audiences.
Our Simple Evaluation Process
Every great collection deserves a team that knows how to bring it to market the right way. We’ll walk you through every step, from evaluation to sale, because that’s how we do business: say what we’ll do, then do what we said.
Step 1
Tell Us What You Have.
Whether it’s a single prized piece or a basement full of boxes, it all starts with a conversation. Reach out and give us the rundown so we can start with a general idea of what you’re sitting on. We’ve seen it all, and we’re always excited to hear what you’ve got.
Step 2
We Gather All the Information Needed.
Once we know what we’re working with, we’ll ask for as much information as you can provide, which might be photos, descriptions, spreadsheets – whatever you have. If a physical inspection is workable, we’ll set one up, but we can also operate with FaceTime or other digital tools remotely.
Step 3
We Provide an Initial Evaluation.
With all your details we’ll do our homework, checking comps and market values, giving you a clear, honest assessment of what your collection might be worth.
Step 4
We Discuss Your Goals.
This is where it gets personal. Every seller is different. An estate has distinct needs compared to a lifelong collector downsizing and the timeline may be fast or slow, among many other variables. We’ll sit down with you, talk through your options, and build a plan that fits your pace and priorities.
Trusted Partners
